Generosity vs. Access: The Effects of Subsidy Policy on Price and Quality of Child Care (Job Market Paper) [PDF]
Quality child care can improve low-income children's long-run outcomes. To increase access to high-quality care, the largest child care program in the United States gives states $12.4 billion annually to fund child care subsidy programs. Given a fixed budget, states trade off serving more families against giving larger subsidies to fewer families. It is unclear which allocation is better for eligible families. I first show that market quality and prices change with the number of subsidized families and the maximum subsidy. To identify the effect of each, I use variation in application fixed costs across space and in the maximum subsidy across time, space, and provider type. I find that a higher maximum subsidy increases average out-of-pocket payments and subsidizing more local families increases the probability that a neighborhood has a higher-quality provider. Motivated by these findings, I estimate a model of the child care market with endogenous prices, quality, and number of subsidized families. I use the model to evaluate a reform Wisconsin adopted in 2022 after a federal budget increase. I compare the reform, which increased the maximum subsidy by 130% on average, against using the same budget to offer smaller subsidies to more families. Under the larger subsidy, 17% more low-income children enroll in either public care or high-quality private care relative to subsidizing more families. However, 19% more eligible children forgo formal care overall. Higher prices explain 61% of this decline. As a result, consumer surplus for eligible families is 17% lower and producer surplus is 2% lower.